Information

What Are Loot Boxes? How They Work, Why Regulators Call Them Gambling-Like, and What the EU's New Digital Fairness Act Would Change for Games Like EA FC and BGMI

The European Commission has proposed banning paid loot boxes and pay-to-win for children, forcing games to show odds and real-money prices, and letting every player switch loot boxes off. Here's what a loot box actually is, how gacha and pity systems work, how virtual currency hides prices, how countries from Belgium to South Korea regulate them, and where India stands.

Zerocade · 7 min read
ShareWhatsAppX
Official EA Sports FC 26 screenshot from EA's Steam store page
Image: Electronic Arts

The short version

  • A loot box is a paid random reward. You spend real money, or a currency bought with real money, without knowing exactly what you'll get. Card packs in EA FC and "pulls" in gacha games like Genshin Impact work the same way.
  • On November 11, the European Commission proposed the Digital Fairness Act (DFA). It would ban paid loot boxes and pay-to-win for minors, require odds and real-money prices to be shown, and let all players switch loot boxes off.
  • Countries already treat loot boxes very differently: Belgium calls them gambling, South Korea forces odds disclosure, and the UK leaves it to the industry.
  • India has no loot box law. Its 2025 online gaming law bans real-money games, but loot boxes you can't cash out probably fall outside it.

What a loot box is

Strip away the animation and a loot box is simple: you pay, and the game picks a reward at random from a list. Some items are common, some are rare, and the rare ones are usually what players actually want.

They come in a few forms:

  • Paid boxes and packs. EA FC's Ultimate Team packs are the best-known example. You buy a pack and get random players.
  • Gacha pulls. Named after Japanese capsule-toy machines, gacha games like Genshin Impact sell "pulls" on a banner, with characters rated by stars.
  • Crates and spins. BGMI sells crates and lucky spins using its UC currency.
  • Earned boxes. Some games hand out boxes for playing. Most rules, including the EU's proposal, focus on the paid kind.

How gacha and "pity" work

Gacha games add a safety net called pity. The idea is to guarantee a rare item if you've been unlucky for long enough. HoYoverse's games, for example, guarantee at least a 4-star item every 10 pulls, and some gacha games guarantee a 5-star after 80 or 90 pulls.

Pity sounds generous, and it does cap how unlucky you can get. But it also sets a price: if the top prize is guaranteed at 90 pulls, the real worst-case cost of that character is 90 pulls' worth of money. Most players never do that maths, which is part of why regulators want odds and prices shown up front.

Zerocade chart of how countries regulate loot boxes: Belgium treats them as gambling, the EU's proposal and Brazil ban paid loot boxes for minors, Australia uses age ratings, South Korea, China and Japan require odds disclosure or ban some mechanics, the UK relies on industry rules, and the Netherlands and India have no specific rule

Image: Zerocade

How virtual currency hides the price

Most games don't sell loot boxes for rupees or dollars. They sell a currency first, then sell boxes for that currency. That extra step makes prices much harder to judge.

Take EA FC 26 on Steam. FC Points come in bundles of 100, 500, 1,050, 1,600, 2,800, 5,900, 12,000 and 18,500, priced from $0.99 to $149.99. Pack prices don't line up neatly with those bundles, so you often have to buy more points than you need, and the leftovers nudge you towards the next purchase.

BGMI works the same way in India. On one top-up site, 60 UC costs ₹75, 660 UC costs ₹750 and 8,100 UC costs ₹7,500, and crates are priced in UC, not rupees.

What the EU's Digital Fairness Act would change

The DFA is a proposed regulation, so once passed it would apply directly in all 27 EU countries. It replaces a 2005 consumer law and covers a lot more than games, from hard-to-cancel subscriptions to fake countdown timers. For games, the key parts are:

RuleWhat it would mean
Odds and contentsGames must show what a loot box can contain and the chance of each item.
An off switch for everyoneAll players, adults included, get an easy way to turn paid loot boxes off.
No paid loot boxes for minorsPaid boxes can't be sold to children.
No pay-to-win for minorsPaying to win, or to skip artificial difficulty, is banned for children too.
Real-money pricesItems bought with virtual currency must show their real cost, or an estimate.
Currency off by default for kidsIn games aimed at children, paid currencies stay off unless a parent turns them on.
Engagement tricksPlayers can switch off daily login rewards, streaks, penalties for missing them, and pushy notifications.

Companies that break the rules could be fined up to 6% of global annual turnover.

Consumer Commissioner Michael McGrath framed it as fairness: "We are not making it harder to do business, we are making it harder to do business unfairly."

The games industry strongly disagrees. Video Games Europe and the European Games Developer Federation called the proposal "unworkable, unjustified and disproportionate", saying existing protections like PEGI ratings and parental controls already work.

Official Star Wars Battlefront II screenshot from EA's Steam store page

Image: Electronic Arts

Why regulators care

The turning point was Star Wars Battlefront II in 2017. Players worked out how much grinding or spending it took to unlock heroes, and the backlash was so big that EA switched off all in-game purchases hours before launch.

Research followed. A 2018 study of 7,422 adult gamers by Zendle and Cairns found that the more people spent on loot boxes, the more severe their problem gambling tended to be. The link was stronger than for other in-game purchases. It showed a connection, not that loot boxes cause gambling problems, but it shaped a lot of later policy.

Some games simply dropped them. Overwatch 2 replaced loot boxes with a battle pass when it launched in 2022.

How other countries handle them

  • Belgium (2018): ruled that paid loot boxes in games like Overwatch, FIFA 18 and CS:GO were illegal gambling. EA FC Points still aren't sold there.
  • Netherlands: fined EA €10 million over Ultimate Team packs, but the country's top administrative court overturned it in 2022.
  • UK (2023): decided not to legislate, and the industry agreed to its own principles instead, including parental consent for under-18s.
  • China (2017): games must publish loot box rewards and odds.
  • Japan (2012): banned "complete gacha", where you have to collect a whole random set to win a prize.
  • South Korea (2024): odds must appear on the purchase screen, and regulators found 266 games breaking the rule within months.
  • Australia (2024): games with paid loot boxes get at least an M rating, and simulated gambling gets R18+.
  • Brazil (2026): banned loot boxes in games aimed at children and teens from March.

Apple and Google have also required games on their stores to show loot box odds since 2017 and 2019.

Where India stands

India's Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act 2025 bans "online money games": games where you pay expecting to win money or something of value back. Its rules took effect on May 1, 2026, with penalties of up to three years in jail or a ₹1 crore fine.

It doesn't mention loot boxes. One factor in deciding whether a game counts as a money game is whether its items can be cashed out or used outside the game. Most loot boxes, like BGMI crates or EA FC packs, give items you can't sell for money, so on paper they likely fall outside the ban. Law firms say it depends on each game. In-game purchases are taxed at 18% GST.

What to watch

The DFA now goes to the European Parliament and EU governments, who have to agree a final text. That's likely to take until at least 2027, so don't expect changes in your games before 2028. Watch whether the "off switch for adults" survives negotiations, and whether big publishers redesign their games worldwide rather than run a separate EU version.

Found this useful?
Send it to a friend who's been asking.
ShareWhatsAppX
Whodunit
Who did it? Place the suspects and catch the murderer.
Solve today's case →

Keep reading

Official AMD EPYC 9006 banner, AMD's first Zen 6 processors
Up next

Is AMD's Zen 6 Desktop Ryzen Really Delayed? A Well-Known Ryzen Tool Developer Denies the N2X and Summer 2027 Claims: Who Said What, What TSMC's N2, N2P and N2X Mean, What AMD Has Confirmed, and What Ryzen 9000 Costs in India Now

Two days after a Chiphell post claimed AMD's desktop Zen 6 chips had moved to TSMC's N2X process and slipped past Computex 2027, Ryzen tuning-tool developer 1usmus called both claims inaccurate. Here's what each side said, how much to trust them, what TSMC's 2nm variants actually are, what AMD has confirmed about Zen 6, its CES keynote on January 5, and what Ryzen 9000 chips cost in India if you're buying now.

Official screenshot from Devcats' earlier hidden-object game A Planet Full of Cats

Bethesda Confirms 'A Wasteland Full of Cats', a Fallout-Inspired Cat Hunt From Devcats, After an Australian Rating Leaked It: What the Listing Says, Who Is Making It, and What's Still Unknown

22 Nov 2026
Official Intel Core Ultra 9 badge

Intel Nova Lake Leaks Again: a 28-Core Desktop Chip at 5.2GHz, a 16-Core Laptop Chip With DDR5-8000 in a Partner Datasheet, and a SilverStone PSU With Three CPU Cables 'for Nova Lake-S'

22 Nov 2026
Official Nvidia App artwork

Nvidia Fixes Its SSD-Writing Driver Bug With Hotfix 621.35: What Changed, Who Needs It, How Much Was Being Written, How to Check Your PC, and Why a Hotfix Isn't the Same as a Normal Driver

22 Nov 2026
Official Deltarune key art from the game's website

Deltarune Chapter 6 Is Now Playable From Start to Finish, Toby Fox Says, and Chapter 7 Work Has Begun: What's Left, Why There's Still No Date, and What It Costs in India

21 Nov 2026
GPD Win Mini Ultra pricing key visual

GPD Win Mini Ultra Gets a $1,699 Price: Intel's Arc G3 Extreme, 32GB of RAM, an 8-Inch 120Hz Screen and a Keyboard, Plus GPD's Own Frame Rates and How It Compares With the MSI Claw and ROG Xbox Ally X

21 Nov 2026