NewsOfficialPlayStationXbox

Sony Wins the £2 Billion PlayStation Store Lawsuit in the UK: Tribunal Says Sony Isn't Dominant and Its 30% Cut Isn't Unfair, Partly Because You Can Still Buy Discs

The UK's Competition Appeal Tribunal has thrown out the class action that accused Sony of overcharging 12.2 million PlayStation players through its store's 30% commission. The unanimous ruling says PlayStation competes with Xbox, Nintendo and physical games. Here's what the case claimed, why it failed, how it compares with the Apple and Steam cases, and why Sony's plan to drop discs could matter next.

Zerocade · 5 min read
ShareWhatsAppX
Official PlayStation image of the PlayStation Store on a laptop and a phone
Image: Sony Interactive Entertainment

The short version

  • On November 17, the UK's Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed the class action brought by consumer campaigner Alex Neill against Sony "in its entirety". The judgment was unanimous.
  • The claim said Sony overcharged about 12.2 million UK PlayStation players through the PlayStation Store's 30% commission. It was worth almost £2 billion ($2.6 billion) including interest.
  • The tribunal found Sony isn't dominant. PlayStation competes with Xbox, Nintendo and PC, and physical games are an important alternative to digital ones.
  • Nothing changes for PS Store prices in the UK or India. The claimants can still try to appeal.

What the case claimed

Neill's case was filed in 2022 and covered digital games and in-game purchases bought on PlayStation in the UK between August 2016 and February 2026. Its argument went like this:

  • Sony controls the only place to buy digital games for a PlayStation, because there's no other store on the console.
  • It takes a 30% cut of every digital sale and in-game purchase from publishers.
  • That cut gets passed on to players, so they paid more than they would in a competitive market. The claim put the overcharge at about 20%.

When the tribunal certified the case in November 2023, it was valued at up to £5 billion. By the trial, which ran from March 10 to May 8, 2026, damages were put at about £1.49 billion, or about £1.97 billion with interest.

Official PlayStation image of a game collection in the PlayStation Store

Image: Sony Interactive Entertainment

Why it failed

The tribunal disagreed with the case's starting point. Neill argued the relevant market was digital PlayStation games alone. The tribunal took Sony's wider view: people choose a whole system, a console plus where they buy games for it, and PlayStation competes with Xbox and Nintendo in that market.

From there, the main findings were:

  • No dominance. The tribunal said Neill had not shown that Sony is dominant in any relevant market.
  • Physical games count. Discs, bought from shops and sold second-hand, are "likely to be important substitutes" for digital games. Players who own several consoles, or play cross-platform, can also move.
  • The 30% cut isn't proven unfair. Sony's margin wasn't shown to be excessive, and a 30% commission is common across stores.
  • Even on Neill's own market, it fails. The tribunal called his picture of a world with rival stores on PlayStation not credible. Forcing Sony to open up would need a big redesign of the platform.

Sony argued in court that it had "invested years and billions" in PlayStation, and that rival stores would free-ride on it. Neither side commented to Reuters after the ruling. Push Square reports that Neill's team is "considering its options", and an appeal needs the tribunal's or a higher court's permission.

Zerocade timeline of the Alex Neill v Sony PlayStation Store class action, from filing in 2022 and certification at up to £5 billion in November 2023 to the March to May 2026 trial and dismissal on November 17, 2026, with comparison cards for Kent v Apple and Shotbolt v Valve

Image: Zerocade

The disc twist

Here's the part that could matter later. Sony announced in July that it will stop making discs for new games from January 2028. GamesRadar reports the tribunal only learned of this through submissions after the trial. It noted that ending physical sales could remove some of the competition that helped Sony win.

In other words, the ruling looks at the market as it was. If discs disappear, the PlayStation Store becomes the only way to buy a new PS game, and Push Square says that would likely need a fresh case to argue. GTA 6 already shows the shift: its boxed PS5 version reportedly holds only a download code, as we explained in our code-in-a-box guide.

Official PlayStation image of the PS5 Slim with a disc drive

Image: Sony Interactive Entertainment

How it compares with Apple and Steam

CaseStoreClaimStatus
Kent v AppleApp StoreAbout £1.5 billionApple lost in October 2025, seeking to appeal
Neill v SonyPlayStation StoreAlmost £2 billionDismissed November 17, 2026
Shotbolt v ValveSteamUp to £656 millionCertified January 2026, not yet at trial

The difference with Apple is that you can't buy iPhone apps anywhere else, and there's no physical alternative. On paper, the Steam case sits closer to Sony's, since PC players can buy from Epic, GOG and others. Similar PlayStation cases are also at earlier stages in Australia, the Netherlands and Portugal.

What it means for players in India

Nothing directly. The case only covered UK purchases, and India's Competition Commission hasn't opened a probe into console stores. Its actions in gaming so far have targeted Google's Play Store.

PS Store prices here stay where they are. GTA 6 is ₹5,999 for Standard and ₹7,499 for Ultimate when it unlocks at midnight IST tonight, and Marvel's Wolverine is ₹4,999, or ₹3,749 on sale until November 30. Amazon's GTA 6 PS5 bundles suggest a disc drive costs about ₹4,995 more than the Digital Edition.

Official Marvel's Wolverine key art from the PlayStation Store

Image: Sony Interactive Entertainment

What to watch

Watch whether Neill's team asks to appeal, and for the Steam case's trial date. The bigger question is what happens after January 2028, when new PlayStation games stop coming on disc.

Found this useful?
Send it to a friend who's been asking.
ShareWhatsAppX
Whodunit
Who did it? Place the suspects and catch the murderer.
Solve today's case →

Keep reading

Official Deltarune key art from the game's website
Up next

Deltarune Chapter 6 Is Now Playable From Start to Finish, Toby Fox Says, and Chapter 7 Work Has Begun: What's Left, Why There's Still No Date, and What It Costs in India

Toby Fox's Fall 2026 newsletter says Deltarune Chapter 6 is a 'structurally complete draft' you can play from beginning to end, with localization and testing next and a 2027 release still the aim. Chapter 7 has only just started. Here's exactly what was said, what's still missing, how earlier chapters launched, and why the ₹1,099 Steam version already covers it.

Official Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic Remake reveal art from the 2021 PlayStation Showcase

Star Wars: KOTOR Remake Rumoured for a Re-Reveal at The Game Awards on December 10: What the Leaker Said, Five Years of Delays, the '2028' Claim, and What the Originals Cost in India

21 Nov 2026
Official Grand Theft Auto VI key art from the Xbox store

Over 2 Million People Reportedly Used Xbox's 'New Zealand Trick' to Play GTA 6 Early: How It Works, Why It Was Easier on Xbox Than PS5, What Microsoft's Rules Say, and How Early It Got Players in India

21 Nov 2026
Official Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 reveal key art

Modern Warfare 4 Tops October's US Sales Chart in Nine Days, Wolverine Falls to 14th, and Xbox Hardware Spending Jumps 42%: Circana's October 2026 Numbers Explained

20 Nov 2026
Official Grand Theft Auto VI 'Now Available' artwork from Rockstar Newswire

GTA 6 Sold an Estimated 24.6 Million Digital Copies Worth $2.36 Billion by the End of Launch Day, Sensor Tower Says: What That Number Includes, the PS5 vs Xbox Split, and Why Take-Two Still Hasn't Said a Word

20 Nov 2026
Official Path of Exile 2 screenshot from its Steam store page

Path of Exile 2 Goes Free-to-Play on December 11, and Its Director Wants 1 Million Players on Steam: Acts 5 and 6, the Shadow and Duelist, a New Army League, and What Happens to Your Early Access Packs

20 Nov 2026